• Directories
    • Seattle iBusiness Directory
    • Seattle24x7 VC and Angel Directory
    • Seattle24x7 Area Tourist Attractions (& Hotels)
    • Seattle’s Top SEO/AdWords Firms (Top 5)
  • Community
    • E-City
    • People
    • ShopTalk
    • What’s Brewing?
  • Calendar
    • Calendar
  • Venues
    • The Seattle24x7 Conference & Meeting Venues Directory
  • Commentary
    • Advisor X
    • Pioneer Squared
    • Previews & Reviews
    • SiteCynic
    • Tech Humor
  • Jobs Board
  • Contact
    • Seattle24x7 Job Posting Form
    • Seattle 24×7 Company Inclusion Form
    • Calendar/Event Submission
Search
Friday, February 3, 2023
  • About Us
Sign in
Welcome! Log into your account
Forgot your password? Get help
Password recovery
Recover your password
A password will be e-mailed to you.
Seattle 24×7
  • Directories
    • Seattle iBusiness Directory
    • Seattle24x7 VC and Angel Directory
    • Seattle24x7 Area Tourist Attractions (& Hotels)
    • Seattle’s Top SEO/AdWords Firms (Top 5)
  • Community
    • Seattle Public Schools sues TikTok, YouTube, Facebook, Snap, and Instagram over Mental Health Crisis
      2023 New Year’s Resolutions for Seattle CIOs
      EXODUS: Mass Layoffs Arrive, INVITE: Work for Seattle24x7
      Meta’s VR Quest: The Reformation of Facebook VR Is Tied to Microsoft Teams
      AI Comes to MOHAI
      AllE-CityPeopleShopTalkWhat’s Brewing?
  • Calendar
    • Calendar
  • Venues
    • The Seattle24x7 Conference & Meeting Venues Directory
  • Commentary
    • Seattle Public Schools sues TikTok, YouTube, Facebook, Snap, and Instagram over Mental Health Crisis
      22 Best Seattle Podcasts of 2022
      2023 New Year’s Resolutions for Seattle CIOs
      Expedia’s Top Air Travel Hacks for the 2023 Holidays
      Amazon Pulls the Plug on Amazon Care: Big Tech’s Fast, Frugal Focus a Failed Formulary
      AllAdvisor XPioneer SquaredPreviews & ReviewsSiteCynicTech Humor
  • Jobs Board
  • Contact
    • Seattle24x7 Job Posting Form
    • Seattle 24×7 Company Inclusion Form
    • Calendar/Event Submission
Home Advisor X Failure to Launch
  • Commentary
  • Advisor X

Failure to Launch

Twitter
Pinterest
WhatsApp
Email
Print

    by Janet DeDonato,  CEO, Methodologie, @id_360

    The design world watched with much fascination this month as the beloved global brand Gap attempted to update its iconic logo. What ensued is a cautionary tale for every major brand in the world and has generated more questions than answers. It became kind of a global passion play of Who Moved My Cheese?

    Setting aside for the moment whether the new logo was good or bad, and whether springing it on an unsuspecting public was wise or foolish—there have been thousands of blogs and tweets covering both of these topics, with no end in sight—I’ve been pondering the broader implications of what just happened. (And don’t even get me started on the crowd-sourcing bake-off idea.)

    I think that the extent to which people were engaged and outraged is in direct proportion to how much consumers are attached to the Gap. In many ways, the company should be proud that there was such intense emotion generated and that the public cares so much about every move they make. As a point of full disclosure, my relationship with (and respect for) the Gap runs deep and wide. I am currently a consultant, partner, customer, and investor. But this is not really about the Gap. It could be new Coke, Tropicana, UPS, or the Olympic Games.

    What responsibility does a company have to the world at large to “prepare” them for an intended shift in brand image? Why do we think we even have a right to weigh in? Silly question, I suppose, since we all feel we have the right to weigh in now on everything from Lindsay Lohan’s rehab to the level of service from the neighborhood shoe repair. Social media has changed everything, forever.

    The next time a large company wants to respond to shifting market conditions by updating its identity (and, hey designers, isn’t this how we make our living?), what hoops will they need to jump through to avoid this type of public outcry? Just produce a really great new logo? Will our final logo options need to be sent out in a global Survey Monkey, so the world can vote thumbs up or down before the final is chosen?

    Let’s be honest, as this was unfolding, who among us didn’t think “oh god, I’m so glad I didn’t design this logo”? What would have been such a plum project coming in the door quickly devolved into public humiliation for all concerned. My heart goes out to them. Honestly.

    But as I rant, who are all these people who have the time to write endless blogs about Helvetica and gradient boxes? Don’t they have jobs? Oh, wait—global economic meltdown, endless recession, joblessness—sorry, never mind. I digress.

    My real question is this: Do we as designers now have the responsibility to advise our clients to engage the public in discourse or in the process somehow before they set out to alter their identities? Or do we throw caution to the winds and let them, and us, risk a similar outcome? One thing is certain, what the Gap experienced this month will have profound implications for our clients and ourselves going forward.

    Janet DeDonato has served on the national board of AIGA and the Association of Professional Design Firms. She is regarded as an expert in investor communications and has designed and managed more than 100 annual reports in her 25-year career. Her experience spans all aspects of brand strategy and corporate communications and her clients include Amylin, BNSF Railway, Boeing, Microsoft, and Potlatch.

    • TAGS
    • direct proportion
    • everything
    • Gap
    • global passion
    • intense emotion
    • investor
    • logo
    • new coke
    • public outcry
    • Time
    Twitter
    Pinterest
    WhatsApp
    Email
    Print
      Previous articleReporting the Reports: Methodologie Guides the Fortune 100
      Next articleVisual Interaction Designer, Google
      Larry Sivitz

      RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

      Advisor X

      Seattle Public Schools sues TikTok, YouTube, Facebook, Snap, and Instagram over Mental Health Crisis

      Advisor X

      How Much YouTubers Get Paid for Millions of Views

      Advisor X

      Breaching the Great Wall: Localizing Games for China

      Latest Press Releases

      Spotlight Jobs

      • Director of Content Marketing and Strategy

      • Content Strategist, Facebook

      • Digital Advertising Account Executive, Seattle24x7

      Welcome to Seattle24x7, the first-ever Puget Sound online business community and the one-and-only, dot-com combination of Company Directory, Community and Commentary.
      Contact us: [email protected]

      Community

      Seattle Public Schools sues TikTok, YouTube, Facebook, Snap, and Instagram over Mental...

      2023 New Year’s Resolutions for Seattle CIOs

      EXODUS: Mass Layoffs Arrive, INVITE: Work for Seattle24x7

      Commentary

      Seattle Public Schools sues TikTok, YouTube, Facebook, Snap, and Instagram over Mental...

      22 Best Seattle Podcasts of 2022

      2023 New Year’s Resolutions for Seattle CIOs

      • Privacy
      • Site Map
      © Seattle 24×7 1999-2018. All rights reserved.